Best Motorcycle Insurance Companies: Top Picks for 2024

Best Motorcycle Insurance Companies: Top Picks for 2024

Written by Pierce Bryant
March 28, 2024

Motorcycle insurance is essential for every rider, as it provides financial protection in the event of an accident, theft, or damage. With numerous companies offering various coverage options and discounts, it can be challenging to find the right insurance provider for your specific needs. The importance of making an informed decision when choosing a policy cannot be understated, as it ensures that you have peace of mind while enjoying your ride.

In order to evaluate the best motorcycle insurance companies, a few key criteria should be considered. These include the range of coverage options, available discounts, financial strength, and customer satisfaction. By taking into account the experiences of other riders and the reputations of various providers, you can make an informed choice on a company that offers the right balance of value, coverage, and service for your budget and riding style.

Researching Motorcycle Insurance Companies

It's crucial to conduct thorough research before selecting a motorcycle insurance provider. Carefully evaluating various factors will help ensure you choose a company that best fits your needs and offers optimal coverage at a competitive price.

When researching motorcycle insurance companies, consider:

  1. Reputation and financial stability: Check the provider's financial rating and customer reviews to determine its financial stability and overall reputation for delivering quality service.

  2. Coverage options: Assess the available coverage options, such as liability, comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist, and medical payments. Look for a company that offers a wide range of coverage to tailor the policy to your needs.

  3. Discounts and rewards: Many insurance providers offer discounts and additional benefits for safe riders, multi-policyholders, or by bundling with other insurance products. Examine the discounts and rewards available to maximize potential savings.

  4. Customer service and claims process: Look for companies known for their prompt and efficient customer service, and a smooth claims process. A simple and effective claims experience is vital if you ever need to use your insurance.

  5. Pricing and payment flexibility: Assess the cost of premiums and whether the company offers flexible payment options to fit your budget. Price should not be your only consideration, but it's essential to factor in affordability.

To help get started, here are some highly-rated motorcycle insurance companies based on the search results:

Remember, diligently researching motorcycle insurance providers and comparing them based on the factors mentioned above will help you make an informed decision and protect your investment with confidence.

Criteria for Evaluation

When determining the best motorcycle insurance companies, several key factors are taken into consideration. These factors ensure that the providers chosen excel in delivering comprehensive coverage, competitive pricing, reliable customer service, and long-term financial stability.

Coverage Options

The coverage options offered by an insurance provider play a crucial role in the evaluation. Ideally, a leading company should provide a wide range of coverage options to meet the diverse needs of motorcycle riders. These options typically include liability, collision, comprehensive, medical payment, uninsured/underinsured motorist, and accessory coverage. Additionally, standout companies may offer unique options, such as roadside assistance, trip interruption, or custom parts coverage.

Customer Service Quality

An essential aspect of any insurance provider is the quality of customer service. The best companies will have knowledgeable and friendly agents who provide prompt and efficient assistance. Responsiveness to claims, accessibility through multiple communication channels (phone, email, online chat), and overall customer satisfaction ratings are taken into account when evaluating the customer service quality.

Financial Stability

Financial stability is another important factor, as it indicates an insurance company's ability to meet its policyholders' claims. Well-established companies with strong financial ratings demonstrate a high level of reliability. Notable agencies, such as AM Best and Standard & Poor's, provide ratings that can assist in identifying financially stable insurance providers.

Pricing Competitiveness

Lastly, pricing competitiveness is critical for motorcycle riders searching for affordable premiums without sacrificing coverage. Leading insurance providers strive to offer competitive rates while maintaining adequate coverage. Riders should consider rates from multiple insurers to identify the best value, recognizing that factors such as motorcycle make and model, rider age, and driving history can influence premium costs.

By thoroughly evaluating these key criteria, consumers can confidently choose an insurance provider that meets their needs and offers the best overall motorcycle insurance experience.

Top Motorcycle Insurance Companies

When searching for the best motorcycle insurance, it's essential to consider various factors such as coverage options, customer service, and discounts. Based on comprehensive research and evaluation, here are some of the top motorcycle insurance companies in 2024:

1. Markel: Markel is known for catering to hobbyists, offering specialized coverage for motorcycle collectors. While their full-coverage policies might be slightly more expensive, averaging around $39 per month, the company provides a multivehicle discount that can help motorcycle enthusiasts save money.

2. Harley-Davidson Insurance: As the name suggests, Harley-Davidson Insurance is an excellent choice for Harley owners. This company focuses on providing tailored coverage for Harley-Davidson motorcycles, while other insurers only offer general discounts for this brand.

3. Allstate: Allstate ranks high among motorcycle insurance companies, particularly for new and young riders. With its affordable policies and bundling discounts, Allstate can help riders save on coverage costs. Additionally, the company has a well-established reputation in the insurance industry.

Here is a brief comparison of these top insurance companies:

Motorcycle Insurance Company Target Clientele Specialty/Benefits
Markel Hobbyists, Collectors Multivehicle discount
Harley-Davidson Insurance Harley owners Custom coverage for Harley-Davidson motorcycles
Allstate New and young riders Bundling discounts

Before selecting a motorcycle insurance company, riders should consider their individual needs and preferences. These top companies offer tailored coverage options and benefits, catering to different types of riders and ensuring suitable coverage at competitive prices.

Detailed Reviews

Foremost offers a solid range of coverage options, providing everything from liability to comprehensive and collision coverage. Their pricing is considered competitive in the market, making them an attractive choice for those seeking value and a range of coverage options. Customers have noted Foremost's prompt claims processing and above-average customer service experience, making it a reliable choice for motorcycle insurance.

American Family has earned a reputation for having a low level of complaints, reflecting their commitment to customer satisfaction. While their coverage options are fairly standard, their focus on customer service sets them apart from the competition. Pricing for American Family policies is competitive, and they offer several discounts like safe driving, multiple policies, and loyalty discounts.

Erie excels in collision repair coverage, offering a streamlined process for policyholders who encounter accidents. In addition to their standard coverage options, Erie offers several optional coverages for customizing your policy. Their pricing is reasonable, and they provide various discounts for insuring multiple vehicles, having a clean driving record, and more.

Progressive is renowned for their policies tailored to military members and their families. They offer a wide range of coverage options and boast a strong customer service reputation. Progressive is known for offering competitive prices and various discounts, such as paid-in-full, responsible driver, and military service discounts. Their Accident Forgiveness program is a standout feature, ensuring premiums won't increase after your first accident if you have no previous accidents on your record.

Safeco provides great value for motorcycle enthusiasts, offering extensive coverage options and multiple discounts for policyholders. This insurer is particularly attractive for those who prioritize affordability without sacrificing coverage quality. Safeco has built a solid reputation in the industry and is known for their responsive and efficient claim handling process.

Allstate caters to both new and young riders, offering tailored coverage options to meet their specific needs. They have several programs such as a new motorcycle replacement and accident forgiveness which help policyholders navigate the insurance world with confidence. Allstate's competitive pricing and various discounts make it accessible for a diverse range of motorcycle riders.

USAA focuses on serving military members and veterans, and their motorcycle insurance policies reflect this commitment. They offer competitive prices and several discounts, like bundling policies and good driving records. Customers appreciate USAA's excellent customer service and efficient claims process and have reported high levels of satisfaction.

Markel is the preferred choice for motorcycle hobbyists and collectors, offering specialized coverage and multi-vehicle discounts. Although their full coverage policy might be slightly more expensive, they make up for it with tailored plans specific to customers' needs. Markel's strong industry reputation and commitment to excellent customer service make it a desirable choice for those with unique coverage needs.

Tips for Choosing the Right Insurance Company

When looking for the best motorcycle insurance company, it's essential to consider various factors to make an informed decision catered to your needs and preferences. Here are some top tips to help you choose the right insurance company.

  1. Coverage options: Evaluate the type of coverage offered by different insurance companies and ensure they cater to your requirements. Some companies might have a greater variety of coverage options, such as comprehensive, collision, and uninsured/underinsured motorist protection.

  2. Customer satisfaction: Look for companies that have a good reputation for customer service, quick claim responses, and overall client satisfaction. Many companies conduct surveys to rate their performance, so researching how satisfied other customers are with their motorcycle insurance can provide helpful information.

  3. Discounts: Search for companies that offer discounts or bundle policies to lower your motorcycle insurance premium. Some common discounts include multi-policy, safe rider, and anti-theft device discounts. Make sure you're aware of the discounts you're eligible for so you can take advantage of potential savings.

  4. Financial stability: A financially strong insurance company can give you peace of mind, as they're more likely to cover claims without any problems. Look for ratings from independent organizations that assess and rate financial stability, such as A.M. Best and Standard & Poor's.

  5. Company-specific features: Some insurance companies might offer unique features that cater to your specific needs. For example, some companies might have better policies for new riders, seasonal riders, or collectors.

  6. Compare quotes: Obtain quotes from several different insurance companies to determine which one offers the best value for the coverage you need. Don't forget to evaluate both price and coverage options when comparing quotes.

By taking the time to carefully consider your needs, researching various options, and comparing quotes, you'll be able to find the motorcycle insurance company that's best suited for you.


In this article, we have presented information to help you make an informed decision when selecting the best motorcycle insurance provider. It is important to remember that a variety of factors should be taken into consideration while evaluating the ideal insurance company to fit your specific needs.

Some of the top insurance companies for motorcycle coverage in 2024 include:

  • Foremost: Best Overall
  • American Family: Best for Low Level of Complaints
  • Erie: Best for Collision Repair
  • Progressive: Best for Military Members
  • GEICO: Best for Affordability
  • Markel: Best for Multiple Bikes
  • Harley-Davidson: Best for Discounts
  • Safeco: Best for Value
  • Allstate: Best for New & Young Riders
  • USAA: Best for Military & Veterans

As you evaluate your options, keep in mind the aspects that matter most to you, for example, cost, available discounts, coverage options, customer service, and claim process. Taking the time to compare various companies will assist you in finding a provider that aligns not only with your budget but with your requirements, as well.

Making a knowledgeable and informed decision when choosing a motorcycle insurance provider helps to ensure that you receive the necessary coverage in case you face any unfortunate events while enjoying the freedom of the open road. Remember to review your policy periodically, as changes in life circumstances may impact your insurance requirements, and it's always a good idea to stay informed about the latest offerings in the ever-changing insurance landscape.